Saturday, 28 November 2009

Press Release: US Human Genome Project Announces "Race" Does Not Exist

Race is a disproved hypothesis

Race is a disproved hypothesis

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Contact: Atty. Francis L. Holland
Blogs: American Journal of Color Arousal, etc.
URL: http://amjca.blogspot.com
Phone: 55 (73) 9123-2538
Skype: FazInformatica2005

US Human Genome Project Announces
"Race" Does Not Exist!

With the 2010 United States Census nearing, the word "race" will inevitably become a political lightning rod, with political groups debating what "races" should be included and excluded. Missing from the discussion is science: Why do we use the word "race" ubiquitously, in journalism and discussions, over 40 million times in print in the United States over the last year (according to Google), even after the US Government's Human Genome Project has announced that biological race simply does not exist?

Atty. Francis L. Holland of the American Journal of Color Arousal (AMJCA) has developed a new Easy-Widget that takes readers directly to the Human Genome Project webpage's discussion, explaining why the centuries-old hypothesis of biological "race" is not supported, and is disproved, by Government-supported DNA research (conducted during the Bush Administration). As the journal Nature Genetics stated in the article entitled "Race and the Human Genome,"

With very rare exceptions, all of us in the US are immigrants. We bring with us a subset of genes from our homelands, and for many Americans, often first-generation but more commonly second-generation, the plural noun 'homelands' is appropriate. From this perspective, the most immediately obvious characteristic of 'race' is that describing most of us as Caucasian, Asian or African is far too simple. Despite attempts by the US Census Bureau to expand its definitions, the term 'race' does not describe most of us with the subtlety and complexity required to capture and appreciate our genetic diversity. Unfortunately, this oversimplification has had many tragic effects. Therefore, we need to start with the science . . .

In an another statement, the US Department of Energy Human Genome Project simplifies for the public gist of the "Race and Human Genome" article above, stating unambiguously that empirical science has disproved the hypothesis of "race":
DNA studies do not indicate that separate classifiable subspecies (races) exist within modern humans. While different genes for physical traits such as skin and hair color can be identified between individuals, no consistent patterns of genes across the human genome exist to distinguish one race from another. There also is no genetic basis for divisions of human ethnicity. People who have lived in the same geographic region for many generations may have some alleles in common, but no allele will be found in all members of one population and in no members of any other.
Atty. Holland argues that sociological definitions based upon the term "race" are so tainted by their relationship with debunked biological theories that the term "race" has become so hopelessly ambiguous as to be meaningless, irreconcilable and perpetually controversial.

The attached double-click Easy-Widget, hosted at WidgetBox (HTML below), says:

"Skin Color Exists. Black and white subspecies (races) of humanity are a false and anachronistic hypothesis. Learn More: Human Genome Project."

This easy widget takes readers directly to the "Minorities, Race and Genomics" webpage of the US Department of Energy, where readers can evaluate for themselves whether our public discussion and vocabulary have become hopelessly disconnected from the scientific advances that should be helping to guide our discussions.

Here is the HTML code for the "Skin Color Exists" Easy-Widget:



Atty. Holland encourages the thousands of blogs in the afrosphere to post this widget. Doing so challenges our daily conversations of "race" to include the fact that, as a matter of DNA-based biological science, "race" just doesn't exist, and using the tainted biological term in sociological discussions misleads and frustrates reconciliation efforts between and among people of different skin colors.

The debate is inevitable. How will the 2010 Census use the term "race" and will the term itself further mislead the public about basic DNA genomic science? These issues will be hotly debated throughout preparation for the 2010 and beyond.

So, how can the science be simply explained? "Skin color groups and national heritage are facts of political life. However, DNA and genomic science have revealed over the last decade that the hypothesis of "race" is not supported by science, even though we have relied upon this hypothesis as a virtual article of faith for over 400 years."

Contact: Atty: Francis L. Holland
Blog: American Journal of Color Arousal, etc.
URL: http://amjca.blogspot.com
Phone: 55 (73) 9123-2538
Skype: FazInformatica2005

References:

http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/minorities.shtml

http://www.nature.com/ng/journal/v36/n11s/full/ng2150.html

http://amjca.blogspot.com/

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/francis-l-holland/why-the-race-word-is-wron_b_66014.html

http://amjca.blogspot.com/2009/11/why-is-word-race-used-80-times-more.html

Tuesday, 24 November 2009

White Professor in Brazil Immediately Arrested for Insulting Black Student on Basis of Skin Color

This evening on Globo News, Brazil, as I watched, a news reporter announced that a professor who insulted a Black female student in a bar in Ilhéus, on the basis of skin color, was immediately arrested at the bar after the student filed a complaint with local police.

Notably, it is not necessary under the Brazilian Constitution to prove that the professor "is a racist" before he can be imprisoned for his "racist" behavior during a particular incident. It is sufficient to demonstrate that he said the offensive words and that the words were associated with the victims "race" [skin color] As the Brazilian blog below points out, an outward "racist" "reaction" is sufficient for the culprit to be immediately arrested, with no need to prove that he always has this reaction and therefore "is a racist." It is sufficient that he engaged in "racist" behavior in the case in question.

A Brazilian blog called "Society Demands Justice" also reported the case, but without a link to a Brazilian source:
Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Professor tem reação racista com aluna /
"Professor Has Racist Reaction Against a Student"

"Neguinha do cabelo chapado", este foi o discurso racista do professor Saulo da Cruz Ramos, na cidade de Ilhéus. A vítima foi a aluna Jamile Catarino Pacheco que ao ouvir as palavras de ofensa, não pensou duas vezes e procurou a delegacia para denunciar a atitude de Saulo.

Translated: Black little thing with pressed hair were the racist words that professor Saulo da Cruz Ramos in the city of Ilhéus. The victim was the student Jamilie Catarino Pacheco, who, after having heard the offensive words, didn't think twice before seeking out local law enforcement officials to denounce the professor's attitude [as expressed in his statements].

O professor, além de falar palavras de agressão para a jovem, disse que "nego com ele não tem vez". Ao sair da delegacia, os policias foram ao bar, onde Saulo estava e deram voz de prisão. A família de Ramos tentou fazer com que Jamile retirasse a queixa, mas não houve êxito. A estudante permaneceu com seu posicionamento e, como racismo é um crime que não tem fiança, o professor irá permanecer preso, até Deus sabe quando.

The professor, in addition to saying agressive words to the young woman, said, "there's no room for Black thing like like him [referring to a Black man present]. Leaving the police station, the police went directly to the bar, where the professor was, and announced that he was under arrest.

The professor's family tried to convince Jamile to withdraw her complaint, but they were unsuccessful. The student maintained her position and, since acts of racism are a crime for which bail is not available, the professor will remain imprisoned until God only knows when.

Que feio para uma pessoa que é vista como educador e tem conhecimento nas leis e informações sobre os direitos humanos.

Such ugly behavior for a person who is seen as an educator with knowledge of the laws and information about human rights.

1 comentários:

Francis L. Holland Blog disse...

Infelizmente, se o professor for fazer a mesma coisa nos Estados Unidos, não ia ser crime. Tem muitas coisas faladas nos Estados Unidos que são criminais, mas chingamentos a base de cor não ficam entre as coisas ilegais.

http://francislholland.blogspot.com

Sunday, 22 November 2009

Color-arousing Republican Senator Lamar Alexander Says Medicaid is a "Medical Ghetto"

Jack and Jill Politics reports that Republican Senator Lamar Alexander is trying to use dog-whistle, color-arousing to turn white and even Blacks against Medicaid, by calling Medicaid a "medical ghetto."
“This bill is historic in its arrogance. Arrogant in its dumping of 15 million low income Americans into a medical ghetto called Medicaid that none of us or any of our families would ever want to be a part of for our healthcare.” Sour, Sorry Sen. Lamar Alexander Calls Medicaid “Medical Ghetto”
I disagree that this is "racist" for fundamentally important reasons based in an underling biological fact; "race" does not exist and even though Lamar Alexander is appealing to the belief that "race" exists, it's still not "racism".

Lamar Alexander's words are an appeal to color-aroused ideation, emotion and political behavior. Jack and Jill Politics still uses the words "race", "racism" and racial, as if these have any meaning in light of recent science proving the terms to be utterly without basis in biology.

I'm from a new generation of thinkers and writers who don't try to describe everything as "racist" just because it's easier, more conventional and more familiar. Thankfully, when researchers discovered the existence of DNA (Deoxyribonucleic acid), they created an abbreviation that everybody could understand but that did not compromise the underlying science.


"Race" is a shorthand way of saying many different things that are utterly unrelated to and dismissive of the underlying science. Every iteration of the word "race", including "race", "racial", "racist" and "race-based" compromises the underlying science because the Human Genome Project has conclusively proven that there is no evidence of the existence of "race" anywhere in the entirely mapped human genome. So, the term "race" is not a reference to biology; it's a negation of everything we have learned over the past century (and particularly the past ten years) about our common genetic biology.

(Oh, you're only referring to "sociological race", but not "biological race"? Try to explain that to Americans in a thirty-second commercial! It's an impossibly complex concept that even people who have studied "race" in college don't really understand and assimilate.)

As I commented at JJP, every time you say the word "racism", you are effectively conceding that you are from a different sub-species than whites. Whites have very effectively taught you to campaign against your own interests by AGREEING WITH THEM that biological "race" exists.

Once you agree that Blacks are a separate sub-species, it's a natural step for whites and even Blacks to agree that Blacks are from an inherently inferior sub-species. (Does anyone really believe that the concept of "separate but equal sub-species" will ever gain any adherents? SHOULD it gain any adherents when the known science utterly disproves this sociological hypothesis?)

We can talk about how imputed "race" makes it possible to engage in discrimination based on what the discriminator THINKS is the "race" of another, even when it''s not. It's unlawful in many contexts to discriminate against someone because you BELIEVE they are Black, even when they only have a dark suntan, or you BELIEVE they are gay because of the way that they speak or dress, when they aren't gay. That's "imputed race" and "imputed sexual orientation".

Do you really believe we can explain to America that the reason we insist on using the word "race", even though we know "race" doesn't exist, is because of the imputed race practiced by people who DO believe that "race" exists? That might work if people who don't believe in biological race stopped using the word "race" altogether and started referring to "skin color groups. But, as long as even intelligent Blacks are using the word "race", you can forget about explaining "imputed race" to the American public.

Now, some people will bring in the perfectly legitimate argument that Lamar Alexander is "racist" because first he imputes "race" to Blacks and then he uses terms like "ghetto" to associate Blacks with this "imputed race"

Once you agree to the premise that "race" exists, it makes perfect sense to Blacks and whites alike that the sub-species called "the black race" must have huge differences (and deformities) relative to whites. Otherwise why would Blacks concede that we constitute a sub-species of the human species?

Does it matter that we are considered a sub-species of the human species? Would you want your five year old's grammar school teacher to explain to him/her and the rest of the class that your child is a member of a sub-species of humanity that is separate and distinct from whites? HAHA If you don't want your child's teacher to say it, then why do you insist on saying it yourself?

The truth is that much of our ideation in America and other countries is based over-interpreting the meaning of skin color and skin-color-associated physical characteristics, like hair type and facial morphology. But the Human Genome Project has discovered, by examining the entire human genetic map, that only oo.o1 percent of the DNA of Black is different from the DNA of whites. We are virtually identical in virtually every way, and so there is no genetic basis for us humiliating, demeaning and marginalizing ourselves by agreeing to be considered a sub-species of humanity, a "race".

People from the Human Genome Project met with Blacks to explain this new understanding, but Blacks seem to have ignored the new science in favor of the old prejudices,like people who prefer to use wood stoves because they're afraid of gas and electricity.

Unfortunately, even the most intelligent of Black people become lazy and seemingly ignorant when it comes to skin color. We would hope that intelligent Black people would explain to the masses that biological "race" was never anything more than a hypothesis -- one that was conceived before humans had any idea that DNA existed, much less what our DNA contained. The disproved hypothesis of "race" has done more to marginalize Blacks than any other concept in American history.

And yet it's still the lingua franca here at Jack and Jill Politics. Oh well. When our generation dies of or retires, our children will assume our institutions and they have grown up in an age where the fact that race doesn't exist is much easier for them to absorb and assimilate. It's just a shame that they have to live with our stubborn ignorance (perpetuating the belief in "race") until we are too old to speak and write any longer.

The truth is that even the most intelligent and educated of Blacks ignore science and steadfastly practice religious obeisance to anachronistic and disproved HYPOTHESIS about human genes. Isn't it time that our language begins to reflect what we've learned about the virtually total lack of difference between Black and white DNA?

Saturday, 21 November 2009

Too Many Blacks Showing Little Intelligence Where "Race" Is Concerned

I'm beginning to think that just as color-aroused illness effects whites, it prejudices Blacks' ability to think logically, making even some of best-educated of us blind to the obvious. For some four hundred years, we've lived as though there were fundamental biological differences between whites and Blacks, with skin color as a marker of those fundamental differences, and these differences were called "race".

It was hypothesized that Blacks and whites (and Latinos and Asians) constituted distinct "races", sub-species of humanity, and further hypothesized that there were any number of intellectual, cultural and biological differences founded in "racial" differences. At one time, we even believed that Blacks' and whites' blood shouldn't be mixed at blood banks.

At some point in the propaganda cycle, many people forgot that "races" were merely a hypothesis, a theory, and never a statement of proven fact. Scientists lacked the understanding of DNA (which was only discovered in the 1950's or so) and lacked knowledge of the human genome to conclusively prove or disprove the theory of "race", but most of the world's institutions were built upon the hypothesis that "race" functioned just as it was hypothesized.

Black college professors were hired to teach their students about "critical race theory" and many may never made it clear to their students that the existence of "race" as a biological matter was a hypothesis, not a self-evident, universal truth. Instead "race" theorists took it as a fundamental and even religious precept that the existence of different skin colors and facial morphology and hair type "proved" "races" existed.

That's fine. They were wrong. It turns out, based on DNA studies and the results of the Human Genome Project, mapping the entire human genome, there isn't any fundamental biological "racial" difference between people that can be perceived on the basis of superficial characteristics.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research, Human Genome Program,
"DNA studies do not indicate that separate classifiable subspecies (races) exist within modern humans. While different genes for physical traits such as skin and hair color can be identified between individuals, no consistent patterns of genes across the human genome exist to distinguish one race from another. There also is no genetic basis for divisions of human ethnicity. People who have lived in the same geographic region for many generations may have some alleles in common, but no allele will be found in all members of one population and in no members of any other." U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research, Human Genome Program
Moreover, there are no "alleles" that can be universally found in one skin color group and never found in another. So one of the fundamental parts of what we need to accept about having brown skin is that our brown skin does not make us fundamentally different biologically from whites. Culture (in the sense of "that which is created by man") and our political and economic group differences make us different from whites - not biology.

This is where I think the most educated Blacks (including the President) show a tremendous blind spot. So wedded are many Black people to the 'word and hypothesis of "race", that they refuse to stop using the word or to make even minimal attempts to disambiguate theories of sociological "race" (sociology being inherently fluid) from biological "race." These educated and educating Blacks are wedded to the word "race" and don't believe that the term "skin color group," which exists, is ever a sufficient alternative for the word race. In their minds, "race" is the only acceptable term for both biological "race" and sociological "race." It is analogous to "hamburger" being the only acceptable word for both "hamburger" and "hot dog."

One would hope that the most-educated people in American society would teach the less educated, but the opposite seems seem to be occurring. Even as the young realize that "racial differences" is useless and destructive terminology, the educated speak as if they were ignorant of the fact. The less-educated often say that "we're all human", without needing scientific proof of the fact. In turns out that the simpler answer is also the scientifically correct one. "We're all alike" biologically, except for minute differences that explain our skin color, facial and hair characteristics, and even those are not reliably distinct.

In spite of all of the recent DNA and human genome evidence that "race" doesn't exist, the most educated Blacks insist on continuing to use the word "race" as if science and the advance of human knowledge didn't exist.

I think this shows that if intelligence is the ability to integrate and synthesize new information as it becomes available, then we would have to conclude that the the USA is one of the stupidest nations in the history of humanity, Blacks and whites alike. We have more information about human genetics than any previous generation did, and yet we still insist that the world is flat and ridicule or abandon those who disagree with us.

When the nightly news says that cigarettes cause cancer, we're able to assimilate that information, eventually ban cigarettes in public places, and try to stop smoking, as the President says he has, for the good of our health.

Compare that to "race". In 2002, seven years ago, the Human Genome Project announced that "race" doesn't exist, because there is no allele in all whites that can't be found among Blacks, and there is similarly no allele among Blacks that cannot be found among some whites.

"Ethnicity" as a biological matter is likewise a not a matter of science, but rather a sociological observation. There is no genetic matter that can be found among all Puerto Ricans that can't also be found among some whites, and vice versa.

Now, I admit that DNA is a relatively new science and many of us don't understand it very well. Many of us know as much about DNA as we know about ice on the moon. Because of its political dimensions, when we discuss "race" we discuss our opinions much more than we discuss or are interested in learning about and discussing scientific facts.

This is analogous to the condition of the women's rights movement in the 1960's. There was little knowledge of what women could do, since women had been carefully excluded from and/or marginalized in virtually every profession except motherhood and homemaking. We treated women as a sub-species of humanity with vastly distinct differences and disabilities that supposedly made women incapable of accomplishing what men could do. Even if they weren't incapable, it still made us inherently uncomfortable to imagine women engaging in these activities.

Women have made tremendous strides and Blacks have often wondered why white women seemed to outpace Blacks in the civil rights department. Part of the reason may be that white women have been accepted as members of the same human species as white men due to the women's rights movement, but Blacks, carrying the cross of "race," have never become generally accepted, even among the most educated Black and white Americans, as members of the same species as white men. Many of us still believe we are a sub-species.

Black studies departments opened on campuses across America to study "critical race theory", instead of "critical color-arousal discrimination theory." The result is that Black students, who are now professionals in every field of endeavor, remain convinced that biological "race" exists and are unwilling to consider the possibility that it doesn't, much less challenge whites who say that "race" exists. And so we have become our own overseers on the plantation of "race", internalizing the oppressors' scarlet letter "R", as if it were branded with a hot iron on our foreheads.

It's a commonly understood precept that if you want people to do something willingly, you have to make it easy for them. Teaching that "race" exists sociologically but not biologically does not make it easier for Americans to stop arguing about "race". The term "race" is inherently controversial because its history is rooted in an anachronistic and scientifically disproved hypothesis that whites and Blacks are fundamentally different biologically, and that therefore it makes sense to search for the "angry gene" and the "stupid gene" and the "poverty gene" among people of different skin colors. It's laughable, really.

Even when the life-preserver of the human genome evidence is thrown by white people to save us from our hypothetical inferiority, the most educated Blacks prefer to drown with the chains of "race" around their necks instead of renewing their minds with the life-preserver of proof that race never existed in the first place.

If a white person says on television, "Race doesn't exist," Blacks will fall upon that person like football team on someone with the ball in his hands. It's naive to say that race doesn't exist, Black intellectuals insist. These Black intellectuals really don't care whether they are arguing in favor of biological or sociological race and they make little or no effort to disambiguate. Therefore, the masses can hardly be blamed if they continue to believe in the newly disproved hypothesis of biological race.

Blacks did not begin to receive even marginally equal treatment from whites until we demanded it. Likewise, whites are not going to acknowledge that Blacks are not fundamentally biologically different until Blacks demand it. And most of us aren't ready to demand it. We're wedded to "race" the way battered spouses are metaphorically wedded to their batterers. We know intellectually that the beatings will never stop, and yet something in our self-image and our sense of efficacy, our enabling and codependency, simply won't let us let go.

God help us! Until we acknowledge that biological "race" does not exist, and determine that no ambiguity will be permitted on this point, we will continue to start the rhetorical and socio-political sprint with whites ten yards ahead of us.

Monday, 16 November 2009

Why is the word "race" used 80 times more often than the phrase "skin color"?



"Salience has generally been described as the attribute of a particular stimulus that makes it stand out and be noticed . . ." Certainly, one attribute that could make a word "stand out and be noticed" is prolific use of a word or phrase in written and spoken language. In fact, anthropologists learn to read dead languages in part by noting the salience of words within that language and using this information to determine how important given words are and what function they serve within the language as a whole.

The question with respect to salience that interests me is why people in the United States of America talk about "race" ubiquitously, while avoiding the phrase "skin color" like the plague? The word "race" has been used 52.500.000 times, even if we exclude contexts in which the words "bicycle", "auto", "election" and "vote" were used, to exclude the possibility that the word "race" was used as anything but a synonym for "skin color group."

If we do not exclude contexts with the words "election" and "vote" (race -bike -bicycle -auto -ocean), during this year in which President Barack Obama was "elected" after a "vote", we find that word "race" has been used 377.000.000 times.

By contrast, a Google search of usage of the phrase "skin color" in the United States, over the last year, shows the phrase has only been used 5.530.000 searchable times in the United States during the last year, in all possible contexts combined. This shows a remarkably numerically superior salience for the word "race" in referring to differences in skin color and skin color groups.

Depending on how the Google search is conducted and which associated words and contexts are excluded in order to focus upon the use of the word "race" in terms of its association with skin color, we find that the word "race" has appeared at least nine times as often as skin color in this context, and as much as eighty times times more often than "skin color."

How and why can and do we talk so much about differences between people associated with skin color,while almost never using the phrase "skin color" when referring to skin color? In the study of color-aroused ideation, emotion and behavior, the perception of the skin color of oneself and of others is a "stimulus." Advertisers study stimuli to determine, for example which stimuli are more likely to prompt target markets to engage in a particular purchasing behavior.

With respect to the "salience" of stimuli, "A stimulus is said to be salient when it is prominent . . . ", i.e. when it is shown and perceived more times. The simple number of times that viewers are exposed to a political commercial for a given candidate or ballot proposition would be an example of the prevalence of a stimulus and political professionals believe that stimuli such as television and radio commercials are more likely to have a desired effect on people's voting behavior if they are salient, i.e. if they are seen more times. Voter familiarity with a particular candidate and the all-important "name recognition" increase with the number of television commercials potential voters see about that candidate.



As the graphic above indicates, "salience" is the "prominence" of a word or phrase in spoken or written language. Numerically, the media and the public in the USA prefer the word "race". The outsized salience of the word "race" as compared to the phrase "skin color" is particularly remarkable in light of the findings and pronouncements of the US Government's Human Genome Project, saying that "race" does not exist and it never did, while that skin color does manifestly exist as a matter of science. According to the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research, Human Genome Program:
DNA studies do not indicate that separate classifiable subspecies (races) exist within modern humans. While different genes for physical traits such as skin and hair color can be identified between individuals, no consistent patterns of genes across the human genome exist to distinguish one race from another. There also is no genetic basis for divisions of human ethnicity. People who have lived in the same geographic region for many generations may have some alleles in common, but no allele will be found in all members of one population and in no members of any other.

In other words, the Human Genome Project has proven that, as a matter of scientific fact, that which we call "race" does not exist as a matter of biology, and so all references to "race" are references to a fallacy.

Assuming that there is some purpose for the continued reference to a biological fantasy when other realistic synonyms are available, what is that purpose. A search for the terms "New York Times" and "race" in usages from the past twelve months (race "New York Times " -racing -auto -champion) turns up 6.360.000 examples. In comparison, a search for the word "skin color" at the New York Times, including all possible contexts, turns up only 126,000 examples. The New York Times prefers to use the word "race" as opposed to skin color by at least a factor of 50:1.

The "salience" of a word in our language effetcts our attitudes, studies and researchers have found. "Salience is an important characteristic of information influencing users' cognitive and emotional states,"says the Journal of Digital Information. Anthropologists study languages that are not used anymore and that no one can read by looking for the number of times each word appears in texts (salience of particular words) and determining thereby what importance the concept expressed by the word possessed to those who spoke the language. Ironically, perhaps anthropologists of the future, trying to understand the English langauge, would conclude that "race" was fifty times more important to Americans than skin color, or that those using the word "race" as opposed to skin color were trying to use the salience of the word to increase its value as stimuli.

In any case, it is apparent when we compare the numerical salience of the phrase "skin color" with the salience of the word "race" that "race" is approximately ten to eighty times more important to us than skin color. I suspect that this is because the term "race" comes pre-infested with the complex meanings that people give to skin color, while skin color is merely . . . skin color. The word "race" is, itself, a "code-word" that Americans use to signify much more than we are facially willing to admit that we are saying, regardless of whether they are Black or white.

This may explain both Americans unwillingness to take onboard the scientific determination that biological "race" does not exist as well as our overwhelming preference for the word "race." It means so much more to each of us than skin color,

When we say "race," we mean something far more complex - something about which people have such differing opinions within and between skin color groups that general agreement with respect to meaning of "race" is not possible. Everyone thinks something different in their mind when they express the word "race" with their mouths. The word enables us to have parallel conversations with people from our skin color group, without confessing to others outside our skin color group what we are actually expressing. It's a perfect codeword.

Now, let's bring this issue home. When I reported the above discoveries to my step-daughter (16), she told me that they don't pay any attention to such issues at her school, except in history class. And she told me that, "Sincerely, I find that I am much more happy not concerning myself with who's "Black" and who's "white" when we're watching a movie. I don't care how many Black people and a white people are in the movie and worrying about that is not going to make me happier. That is her reality, and I hope it will always be that way for her.

Meanwhile, my oldest step-daughter started straightening her hair last month and I just saw my youngest today, for the first time, with straightened hair. They see no untoward relationship between the ubiquity of straightened hair on television and in music videos, on the one hand, and their own fierce determination to straighten their own hair on the other hand. This is to say, they are unaware or uncaring about the society's efforts to socialize them with respect to skin color and skin-color aroused ideation, emotion and behavior, particularly as related to physical characteristics like hair.

This time, rather than argue with a daughter who had straightened her hair, I chose to pretend that I hadn't even noticed. The result is that we have not battled over something that, in any case, I cannot control. But I seriously doubt the person who says they are happier blissfully ignoring color-and feature-associated messages on television, but then chemically and or mechanically straighens their hair. It's rather like saying that it's better to ignore advertisements for McDonald's while eating breakfast lunch and dinner at McDonald's. The cultural salience of the idea that whatever white people have physically is better is having the very effect that is predicted in advertising industry discussions of salience.

Color arousal is like a fever that people have, regardless of skin color, without being aware of it.

Here is an article from Science Daily that does use the phrase "skin color" and addresses physiologically the determinants of skin color. Apparently, people who let science influence their use of language and their opinions prefer the word "skin color" to the word "race".

Sunday, 15 November 2009

African American Political Pundit Asks, "Will color aroused hate destroy America?"

Even though biological "race" does not exist,
the term appears in Google hits
more than 80 times more often than the phrase "skin color".

Thanks for bringing science into the discussion by juxtaposing the concept of "color-arousal" with the disproved and fallacious concept of "race". Skin color exists. As a matter of biology, "race" does not.

I'd have to say that color-aroused hatred has already destroyed America several times (remember the Civil War and Jim Crow apartheid?) and now the question is the degree to which it can be saved from its destruction, and how.

When we ask the question, "Does skin color-aroused ideation and emotion play a role in a public official's behavior?" I think you answered the question yourself about Rep. Joe Wilson, by pointing out that skin-color-based antagonism is a thread that has run through his entire political career. He can't see brown skin without being aroused to ideation and emotion that all-too-often lead to behavior such as he demonstrated in the House chambers, screaming at the President, "You lie!" during a presidential speech.

Whenever anyone (e.g. in the media or blogsphere) uses the word and concept "race", instead of referring to "skin color", they are injecting "race" into the debate.

The US Government's Human Genome Project has concluded that "race" does not exist and it never did:

According to the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research, Human Genome Program:
"DNA studies do not indicate that separate classifiable subspecies (races) exist within modern humans. While different genes for physical traits such as skin and hair color can be identified between individuals, no consistent patterns of genes across the human genome exist to distinguish one race from another. There also is no genetic basis for divisions of human ethnicity. People who have lived in the same geographic region for many generations may have some alleles in common, but no allele will be found in all members of one population and in no members of any other.
In other words, the Human Genome Project has proven that, as a matter of scientific fact, that which we call "race" does not exist as a matter of biology, and so all references to "race" are references to a fallacy.

Although it's hard to bury the concept of race - the idea that Blacks are a subspecies of humanity - after believing this nonsense for four hundred years, there is some evidence that we are making progress.

If you Google the term "color aroused", you will find that the first of nearly 18,000 hits is our "American Journal of Color Arousal".

Of course this is virtually nothing compared to the four hundred million times the fallacious concept of race was referred to in the United States, just in the last year alone. And you find this many hits even if you exclude hits that use the words, "bike -bicycle -election -vote", where the word could be in use referring to something other than skin color.

The fact is that far from overcoming issues of skin color, we are addicted to the disproved concept of "race", and we believe that it is more important to discuss "race" than it is to discuss skin color.

This is very odd, since the only way that most people have to determine a person's imputed "race" is by referring to their skin color.

When the term "skin color" is used one one hundredth as often as the word "race" is used, then you will know that Americans have become willing to move out of the pseudo-scientific fantasies of the slavery era (e.g. the belief that "race" exists) and are more willing to discuss the matter in terms of what actually exists in the natural world: "skin color" and skin color-aroused ideation, emotion and behavior.

In the last year, there are only five million hits at Google for the term "skin color", so mathematically we are approximately 80 times more interested in discussing "race" (which doesn't exist) than we are interested in discussing "skin color", which manifestly DOES exist.

This means that we have a very long way to go and that our obsession with the fantasy of "race" could take us in unpredictable directions, such as civil war and Jim Crow apartheid. We can also elect a Black president in spite of our obsession with "race."

Are Some Chinese People Color-Aroused Against Brown Skin?

Blacks have been warning lately that China is inhospitable to Blacks. Some reported that Blacks were rounded up and beaten in advance of the coming Olympics, as part of an effort to make China prettier. A Washington Post article of today seems to confirm what others have been saying. According to the Washington Post:

Chen Juan, 27, a secretary in an English training school in Beijing, regularly uses skin-whitening products and carries an umbrella on summer days. "For me, the whiter, the better. Being white means pretty," she said. "If someone looks too black, I feel they look countrified and like a farmer. . . . Being white is prettier than being black."

"In my impression, black people, especially Africans, are not clean enough," Chen continued. "To be frank, I just feel black people are too black. Definitely, I wouldn't consider having a black guy as my boyfriend even if he were rich."

( . . . )

Some here say Obama's presidency is causing a major shift in attitudes. Others, however, say many Chinese rationalize his election as a fluke of the American system or suggest that Obama, whose mother was white, isn't "really" black.

"It will be really interesting to see what happens when he comes to visit, because I really think the Chinese have a hard time with it," said Hung. "Nobody has dealt with this question of what this means to our sense of race. It's a kind of self-examination that Chinese -- including myself -- need to go through. Are we racist?" WaPost

As opposed to asking, "are we racist," a question more easily answered in a manner that creates general agreement is the question, "Does Chen Juan's statement in the above quotation show evidence that she is aroused by skin color to experience ideation, emotion and engage in behavior based on the color that significantly impairs her in one or more areas of life?" Chen Juan says quite frankly that she experiences color-aroused ideation, emotion and behavior. She says she would make significant decisions on the basis of color, even if these decisions limited her financial attainment.

As such, she has acknowledged that she really should be screened for Extreme Color-Aroused Disorder, which is an illness in which the perception of the skin color of oneself and/or others arouses ideation, emotion and behavior that causes significant impairment in one or more areas of life, including dating and marriage. The inability to marry someone who would otherwise be appropriate based on the skin color of oneself and the other is an impairment that, in some cases, may cause some people to live alone, not get married, not have children, fail to obtain financial goals which would otherwise be attainable ("I would not marry a wealthy Black man") and be therefore be generally unsatisfied with life based on a behavioral decision that was evoked by skin color aroused ideation and emotion. Although this does not happen in every case, extreme color-aroused disorder constitutes a mental illness in cases where color arousal it causes extreme impairment in one or more areas of life.

Chen Juan says that when she perceives people with brown or black skin, the ideation arises in her that the people are "countrified", which to her is negative. She feels emotional animus toward their skin color (and also toward her own skin color, prompting her to use whitening cream). She says her ideation includes the thought that the color "white is prettier than black." (Many in the United States will defend this ideation as a preference for what they know best, but that doesn't change the reality that skin color is the cue that evokes in such people a sense of revulsion or displeasure, which means that they are, to some degree, color-aroused.)

Chen Juan says that when she perceives, in particular, brown people from Africa, she experiences the ideation that they are "not clean enough." Regardless of whether African dark brown people are clean enough or not, Chen Juan is experiencing an ideation and revulsion that are aroused by the perception of the color of others.

The next crucial question is whether Chen Juan engages in behavior that is aroused by her color-aroused ideation and emotion. The behavioral aspect of color-aroused disorder is crucial since the desire to attack someone based on their skin color may not become a criminal case absent the inability or unwillingness to control the urge to attack someone based on their skin color. It is the color-aroused behavior, legal or illegal, that turns the underlying ideation and emotion into a cognitive behavioral challenge. Chen Jun acknowledges that she does engage in color-aroused behavior.
"I wouldn't consider having a black guy as my boyfriend even if he were rich."

Chen Juan "regularly uses skin-whitening products and carries an umbrella on summer days."

Chen Juan acknowledges that, upon perceiving her own and another's skin color could, she would make a decision about a potential romance with that person, on that basis alone, even where the color-aroused decision could negatively effect her economic status. She would refuse to marry a man whose skin were brown and would marry a lighter skinned man of lesser financial attainment, even if making the decision in this way led to a lower economic attainment for her.

Is Chen Juan racist?

Is Chen Juan "racist"? Whether her color-aroused ideation emotion and behavior include the anachronistic and unscientific belief that there are "sub-races" within the human species, and that these can be distinguished by their skin color (whether she is a "racist") is merely one of many ideational questions that would need to be explored in order for cognitive behavioral therapy to help her to confront the beliefs that guide her emotions and effect her behaviors, toward herself and others, in ways that could impair her self-esteem and functioning.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research, Human Genome Program:

"DNA studies do not indicate that separate classifiable subspecies (races) exist within modern humans. While different genes for physical traits such as skin and hair color can be identified between individuals, no consistent patterns of genes across the human genome exist to distinguish one race from another. There also is no genetic basis for divisions of human ethnicity. People who have lived in the same geographic region for many generations may have some alleles in common, but no allele will be found in all members of one population and in no members of any other."

In other words, the Human Genome Project has proven that, as a matter of scientific fact, that which we call "race" does not exist as a matter of biology, and so all references to "race" are references to a fallacy. Francis L. Holland, The American Journal of Color Arousal


If Chen Juan rejected a potentially lucrative Black client, with color-aroused ideation and emotion leading to this color aroused self-destructive behavior, this would indicate that Extreme Color Aroused Disorder was impairing her functioning in a significant area of her life -her employment and financial prospects.

Likewise, if she remained unmarried and unsatisfied after rejecting marriage to a brown-skinned man based on ideation aroused by his skin color and hers, this would again indicate that Extreme Color Aroused Disorder was impairing her functioning in a significant area of her life - romantic relationships and marriage.

Most interesting in the case of Chen Juan is that she is acutely aware of her own skin color and does not like the skin color that she has. This is why Extreme Color Aroused Disorder is not merely a disorder of ideation aroused by others' skin color, but also a disorder of ideation, emotion and behavior aroused by one's own skin color. Chen Juan reports that, like the late Michael Jackson, she uses skin lightening creams, which means that her perception of color effects not only her reaction to others, but also her own sense of self-worth and "prettiness."

Aroused by ideation that brown skin is lowly, associating brown skin with various devalued societal characteristics, she dislikes her own skin almost as much as she dislikes the skin color of people browner than herself. This ideation and emotion leads her to engage in the color-aroused behavior of spending money, time and effort trying to lighten her own skin, as Michael Jackson did. As such, she should be evaluated for Extreme Color-Aroused Disorder (ECAD) because her ideation and emotion aroused by her own skin color are hurting her self-esteem. She needs to be screened and evaluated for Extreme Color-Aroused Disorder so that she can receive such help as she may need.

I urge readers with comments and additional observations to share them with us at the Francis L. Holland Blog, where the general public, of various skin colors, can benefit from our conversation.

4 comments::

kathy said...

I would guess that skin color itself in China is important, perhaps in the same way, or similar way that it is in Brazil. Because skin color ranges widely in Asia, from very light to very dark, and everything in between.
I think I did read somewhere that darker skin did seem to mean people who were farmers, but in big cities, there are people from everywhere, it seems.
If I remember correctly, China and other communist nations used the US treatment of Blacks as an example of how the US is evil, corrupt and a colonizer, I am pretty sure that this was promoted in China during the Vietnam War, so if anything, I would guess there is a lot of confusion.

The only thing I saw before the Olympics was where the poor housing was just getting, ahh, how do I describe this? Well, instead of tearing down the poor people's homes, they were just barricading them in so no one could see them or how they lived.

I really don't remember anything about Black people being in issue before the Olympics, but I am no expert.

I met a woman walking down the street in Chengdu, we did the eye flick thing I guess, I thought she was an American, but she was actually from France, she was there to study language, nobody even paid attention to us, although any person can be subject to staring or whatever, at least, that was my experience. Not to say that this article is wrong, but I do think it;s pretty complicated to figure out, at least, for me, anyways.

Francis L. Holland Blog said...

Kathy, thanks for your observations based on personal experience. What's "the eye flick thing"?

kathy said...

eye flick, well, i guess that is the flicker in our eyes, of recognition, in a sea of people, that we share something in common, we "recognize" each other, our eyes meet and we stop walking and start talking mid-sentence, "recognition" is the best I can come up with in english. oh, how else can i explain this?

Francis L. Holland Blog said...

I was walking with a white-skinned friend in Providence, Rhode Island when I saw a Black man. I nodded to him and said, "What's up?" and then my friends and I continued walking.

My white friend asked me if I knew the Black man and I informed him that I didn't. But, effectively, we are all part of a club and we recognize each other partly by the color of each other's skin, and then by the nod of recognition.

People watching think that we must know each other, but we don't. We know only that we are part of the same international political group, determined for us and obligatorily accepted by us, determined by our skin color. Even in the midst of hundreds of whites, we know that we are not entirely alone, because we nod out of recognition and the one or a few other Black men (or women) present nod back.